
Today we’re re-drafting the entire rookie WR class as if we’re starting the rookie draft today—injuries, roles, efficiency, age, everything included.
What’s good, Dynasty Rewind community? It’s your boy, Brandon Ghabbour, coming at you with a mid-season re-rank of the 2025 rookie WR class—halfway home, let’s break down the class in tiers, seeing how things have changed since summer. Remember—I run a redraft-focused podcast, Deep Dive Fantasy Football, which is available on all podcast platforms! Follow me on X @deepdiveff or Instagram at deepdivefantasyfootball, or shoot me an email at deepdiveff@gmail.com to get in touch.
Full chart posted in the Rewind Discord and on my socials.
***Stats included throughout this article include player stats through week 9 and do not include week 10.***

Mid-Season Rookie WR Re-Rank: The Top 15
Tier 1
Emeka Egbuka, 23 (TB)
Emeka Egbuka is the undisputed rookie WR1 and already a weekly top-15 play. He leads the class with 7.9 targets per game and a 23.4% target share that’s perfect for a rookie—high enough to eat, low enough to grow. He turns those looks into 15.4 PPR points per game (back-end WR1), 1.95 points per target (best among 25+ targets), 2.15 yards per route run, and 8.9 yards per target. He’s obliterated the “slot-only” narrative: 70% of his snaps are on the outside. Godwin’s December return and Evans’ likely retirement hand him the keys to the best WR factory in football. Baker Mayfield is locked in for the future, Liam Coen dials him up on every third down, and the Buccaneers have consistently produced top-12 fantasy WRs on a per-game basis every year since I can remember. Egbuka is a locked top WR for the next 8 or so years.
Travis Hunter, 22 (JAX)
Travis Hunter might be the most talented human in the class and my WR2 because his snaps were steadily rising on offense before he got injured. He sits at 6.4 targets per game (3rd in class), 17.4% share, 9.1 PPR points per game, 1.4 points per target, and 1.4 yards per route run—numbers dragged by early screens, quick/short passes, and Trevor Lawrence. His route tree has expanded through the season, just like his efficiency and usage. IR buys you the cheapest ticket you’ll ever see on a future WR1. Liam Coen (ex-Bucs) is force-feeding him, and Brian Thomas’ malcontent buzz is real (and the team’s feelings on him). Swap Hunter into Tampa and he’s WR1. Long-term: top-10 ceiling, locked alpha by 2026, should BTJ see a new home, and top 24 WR should he not.
Tetairoa McMillan, 22 (CAR)
Tetairoa McMillan owns the highest target share (24.6%) and converts it into 12.1 PPR points per game, 1.5 points per target, 1.9 yards per route run, and 8.1 yards per target. Bryce Young finally looks like an NFL quarterback. Dave Canales (ex-Bucs) schemed him 5+ targets in every game this season, and Carolina’s WR depth chart is not turning any heads. McMillan is the alpha today and tomorrow. Win-now teams can slide him to WR #2 over Hunter if they so choose—no argument here.
Tier 2
Luther Burden, 21 (CHI)
Luther Burden is the youngest (21) and the single most explosive talent in the class—my pre-draft WR2. He sees only 2 targets per game (6.8% share) and 5 PPR points per game, yet posts 2.5 points per target (2nd), 2.95 yards per route run (class-best), and 11.4 yards per target (class-best). The argument for Burden was never going to be about him being a top-targeted weapon, but rather a hyper-efficient one. Give this man a 20% target share, and he’s a yearly WR1. Ben Johnson’s offense is stacked right now (Odunze, Loveland, DJ Moore), but Moore could be moved in future seasons, and Burden’s YAC is Ja’Marr Chase reincarnated. Patience pays: top-24 WR by 2027, top-5 ceiling (usage dependent).
Matthew Golden, 22 (GB)
Matthew Golden is my WR5 because Green Bay spent their first 1st-round pick on Golden, which is the first WR they have drafted in the top round since Javon Walker in 2002. He’s at 3.6 targets per game, 11.6% share, 6.7 PPR points per game, 1.85 points per target, 1.5 yards per route run, and 9.0 yards per target. Reed and Wicks are banged up, Tucker Kraft is done for the year—Golden will need to step up, along with Christian Watson starting and Romeo Doubs. LaFleur and Gutekunst have turned every Day-2 WR pick in recent memory into a success; a first-rounder will get the red-carpet treatment from me. He projects as a near 1,000-yard WR2-3 for fantasy’s future, with guys like Doubs a free agent in 2025, and Watson and Reed in 2026.
Tier 3
Jaylin Noel, 22 (HOU)
Jaylin Noel is the true complement to Nico Collins and my WR6. He’s at 2.5 targets per game, 7–8% share, ~5 PPR points per game, 1.54 yards per route run (top-6), and good efficiency on limited looks. Stroud has started to trust him as a reliable chain-mover who could be the long-term HOU slot that is capable of hitting 800+ yards every year.
Jayden Higgins, 22 (ARI)
Jayden Higgins is the stylistic copy of Nico Collins, who is currently getting the same volume as Noel (~2.5 targets, 7–8% share, ~5 PPR points per game) but 1.01 yards per route run. Higgins has the talent and potential that I still believe in. The biggest thing that HOU can do to unlock him is give Stroud more time to throw by upgrading the O-Line. Offensive line play is a huge contributing factor to the lack of deep-developing plays, which is Higgin’s calling card.
Jack Bech, 22 (LV)

Jack Bech is my pre-draft Ricky Pearsall—smart, strong, sure-handed, zone-savvy—and the buy-low of the year. He’s barely played; some said because he’s had a similar role as Jakobi Meyers, but Meyers was gone this week vs DEN, and Bech was out-snapped by everyone Thursday night. Second-round capital, best hands on the roster, a refined professional, and a great understanding of the game. That is who Jack Bech is, and if the Raiders start to see that, he can project as the team’s future 2nd most targeted guy after Bowers.
Elic Ayomanor, 22 (TEN)
Elic forces his way to WR9 on sheer volume: 5.8 targets per game (4th), 18% share. The efficiency is brutal—1.0 points per target, 1.2 yards per route run, 6.1 yards per target. Drops, body-catching, and Cam Ward’s moon balls haven’t fixed the college flaws. When Tennessee adds real WRs in 2026, he will slide down the depth chart. Roster him, but don’t go paying up for him.
Dont’e Thornton, 22 (LV)
Dont’e Thornton out-produces Bech today (10.5% share, better PPG) but posts 0.75 points per target and 0.68 yards per route run—yikes. He’s the “shiny toy” red-zone jumper. Brock Bowers’ return caps him at 12% share. Hold, don’t chase.
Tory Horton, 22 (SEA)
Horton would have been up at WR7 for me pre-Rashid Shaheed trade. He’s now the clear WR3 behind JSN (38% share—unsustainable) and Shaheed (already talks about him signing with SEA for the long term, which makes sense given what they traded for him). Horton is explosive and efficient on limited looks; he is just going to have to be very patient now, as are his holders in fantasy.
Tier 4
Pat Bryant, 22 (DEN)
Pat Bryant could be the Courtland Sutton heir in a WR room lacking anyone who instills confidence. Quiet now, but 50/50 balls + Bo Nix’s deep ball = 2026 leap. Deep-league stash.
Chimere Dike, 23 (TEN)
Chimere almost doubles Elic’s points per target on half the looks. When Tennessee cleans the house, Chimere could be the last man standing. Scoop off waivers—now.
Tre Harris, 23 (LAC)
Tre Harris looked like a top-10 rookie WR, and was drafted as such in the summer…until Quentin Johnston woke up, Keenan Allen arrived, and Oronde Gadsden exploded. He’s target #5 on the depth chart with potential to be target #4 post-Keenan. Pretty hard to produce like that.
Tez Johnson, 23 (TB)
Tez Johnson flashed WR2 weeks when Evans/Godwin were hurt, then reverted to drops and wrong routes. He’s WR4 behind Egbuka, McMillan, and a returning Godwin when you think about 2026 and beyond. Efficiency metrics still pop, and the injuries for the Bucs don’t seem to let up this year—roster him due to the injury chaos, but don’t have crazy expectations.
Final Thoughts
This class looked thin pre-draft—turns out it gave us three locked top WRs (Egbuka, Hunter, McMillan), a 21-year-old YAC monster (Burden), and a dozen roster-able pieces. Jack Bech, Chimere Dike, and Pat Bryant are the three names I’m double-checking the trade/waiver wire for.
Drop a rating/review on Deep Dive Fantasy Football—TE re-rank article drops next! Thanks for rocking with me, Dynasty Rewind crew. Let’s keep chasing those titles. Peace!









