1. Jeudy’s 2024 Breakout Performance

Last season (according to @FTSPTSDATA), Jeudy led all WRs with a 0.367 average separation score on horizontally breaking routes (crossers, ins, and out routes). Jeudy led all players in average separation score against Cover 0 (0.471), the purest form of 1v1 man coverage a receiver will see in the NFL. Jeudy has long held a reputation as one of the best pure separators in the NFL, and our numbers seem to bear that out, so why hasn’t it ever translated so neatly into fantasy production?

Jeudy had a career-best season in 2024 with the Cleveland Browns, finishing as the WR12 (Total Pts) in PPR leagues with 90 receptions, 1,229 yards, and 4 touchdowns on 144 targets.

Jeudy set a Browns single-season record with 90 receptions, surpassing Ozzie Newsome’s 89, cementing his role as the team’s primary target. This breakout showcased his ability to deliver high-end fantasy production.

After Deshaun Watson’s season-ending Achilles injury in Week 7, Jeudy averaged 9.8 targets and 122.8 receiving yards per game with Jameis Winston, ranking as the WR5 over that span. This demonstrates his potential with competent quarterback play.

2. Youth and Prime Years Ahead

At 26 years old entering the 2025 season, Jeudy is in his athletic prime, offering several years of elite production potential, which is ideal for dynasty formats.

His elite route-running (96th percentile separation in 2021) and 2024 WR1 performance suggest he can sustain top-12 production with the right circumstances.

3. Favorable Offensive Role

With Amari Cooper traded away in 2024, Jeudy is the Browns’ undisputed WR1, commanding a 22.8% target share last season, despite playing half the year with Cooper ahead of him in the pecking order.

Cedric Tillman and Diontae Johnson fill out the Browns’ receiving room. This limited (Tillman) and untrustworthy (Johnson) competition (outside TE David Njoku) should ensure plenty of targets go Jeudy’s way (144 in 2024) and it has been reported that Kevin Stefanski is going back to his 12 personnel offensive scheme with two tight ends on the field.

The Browns ranked top 5 in pass attempts and 1st in offensive plays over the past two seasons, supporting Jeudy’s target volume (144 targets in 2024 – 7th overall).

Jeudy’s ability to play both slot and outside enhances his role in any offensive scheme. This lends itself to continued volume for Jerry Jeudy as he will never leave the Field as the primary WR (94.2% Snap Share in 2024 – 4th overall in the league).

4. Quarterback Situation as a Buying Opportunity

Per the norm, Scott Barrett tipped me off to this in early 2024.

Jeudy’s success with Winston (WR5 pace) shows he thrives with decent quarterback play. It doesn’t take a ton of imagination to see that Flacco can sustain elite production – the 40-year-old helped Amari Cooper go nuclear and become a league-winner in 2023.

Cooper averaged 12.3 targets, 7.3 receptions, 150.3 yards and caught 3 total TDs (28.4 Fantasy pts per game) during the Flacco stretch of 2023.

Jeudy’s 1,229 yards in 2024 came despite a dysfunctional offense (32nd in scoring) and a rotating quarterback room (Watson, Winston, Thompson-Robinson, Zappe), proving he can produce in suboptimal conditions.

Flacco provides the best immediate option, and it’s likely we’ll see some of Shedeur Sanders and Dillon Gabriel this year, too.

According to PlayerProfiler Data Analysis, Despite having a 61st ranked QB Rating Per Target and the 11th most unrealized air yards (745) in 2024, Jeudy managed to finish 11th in receptions (90), 6th in receiving yards (1,229) and 1st in Total Route Wins (264).

5. Contract Stability

Jerry Jeudy signed a 3 Year, $52 Million contract with the Cleveland Browns on March 19, 2024. The contract runs through the 2027 season and has an average annual value of $17,500,000. It also came with a $6,013,000 signing bonus and $41,000,000 guaranteed.

If the Browns were to even move on from Jeudy, common sense would indicate he’d go to a team with an immediate plan due to his lofty price tag.

6. Risks to Consider

Let’s be realistic with the QB room. Flacco may have some durability issues at 40, Kenny Pickett has never been good news for a WR, and Shedeur Sanders is a wildcard after falling in the draft. Dillon Gabriel doesn’t have a narrative yet, but I call him the Human JUGGS Machine.

With the risk comes the same upside opportunity that we took advantage of in 2024 with Terry McLaurin and Courtland Sutton. There was plenty of fear that Jayden Daniels and Bo Nix wouldn’t support immediate success for the vets, but that was clearly not the case.

Jeudy’s 4 touchdowns in 2024 were modest, so increased red-zone usage is needed for consistent WR1 output.

Outside of David Njoku, Jerry Jeudy is surrounded with unproven pass catchers and has a clear path to being the undisputed WR1. Cedric Tillman did show promise over a stretch in 2024, but his role in the offense as the X receiver doesn’t lend itself to WR1 type usage typically.

7. Realistic Trade Outlooks for Dynasty Teams

Jeudy’s ADP from Dynasty Daddy has him at WR35, valued next to players like Davante Adams, Luther Burden and an early 2025 2nd Round Pick – significantly lower than his WR12 finish in 2024.

Recent Trades (@DynastyDaddy)

Contending Teams (Aiming to Win in 2025)

Jeudy is a perfect addition for contending teams due to his immediate WR1 production (WR12 in Total Points, 2024) and affordable trade cost (mid-to-late 2nd Round pick). His high target share and pass-heavy offense ensure a reliable floor (WR2/3) with WR1 upside, especially if Joe Flacco or a rookie quarterback starts in 2025. He can slot into your lineup as a flex or WR2/3.

Jeudy complements contending rosters needing a consistent, high-volume receiver without spending premium assets (e.g., 1st Round picks). His youth (25) ensures he contributes beyond 2025, unlike older veterans.

Pre-NFL Draft Jerry Jeudy was already a target for me, as his value could spike with a quarterback upgrade. Avoid overpaying, as his current ADP doesn’t reflect his production.

Expect Jeudy to deliver low-end WR1 or high-end WR2 numbers (1,100-1,300 yards, 5-7 TDs) if the quarterback situation improves, making him a key piece for a title run.

Reloading Teams (Balancing Present and Future)

Jeudy is an ideal target for reloading teams due to his blend of immediate production and long-term upside. At 26, he provides WR1/2 output now while retaining value for 3-5 more years, aligning with a reloading team’s timeline. His low acquisition cost allows you to bolster your roster without sacrificing future assets.

Jeudy fits as a bridge asset, offering starting-caliber production while you develop younger players or acquire draft capital. He’s a safer bet than unproven rookies and cheaper than elite veterans like Davante Adams.

Trade a mid-tier veteran (e.g., Calvin Ridley) or a second-round pick to acquire Jeudy. Target rebuilding teams looking to move proven players for picks. If you’re not in contention by mid-2025, you could flip Jeudy for a first-round pick if his value rises with a new quarterback.

Jeudy should maintain a WR2 floor (900-1,100 yards, 4-6 TDs) with WR1 upside, providing flexibility to either start him or trade him for future assets during the season.

Rebuilding Teams (Focused on Long-Term Value)

Jeudy’s age (26) and proven WR1 production make him a cornerstone piece for rebuilding teams. His current WR39 ADP is a steal for a player with his upside, allowing you to acquire a long-term asset without spending high-value picks. His contract stability through 2027 ensures he remains a valuable piece as you build toward contention.

Jeudy has the potential to be a foundational receiver, having just turned 26 in April 2025, who can anchor your roster for years, pairing well with young quarterbacks or rookies you draft later. His breakout in 2024 reduces the risk compared to unproven prospects.

Target Jeudy in deals with contending teams looking to shed younger players for immediate help. Offer a late first-round pick or multiple second-round picks to secure him. His value could rise significantly by 2026 if the Browns upgrade at quarterback, or Shedeur Sanders is able to get on the field and display his talent, making him a +EV target or a keeper.

Jeudy’s floor (WR2) ensures he retains value, while his ceiling (WR1) could make him a top-20 dynasty asset by 2026, ideal for rebuilding teams planning to compete in 2-3 years.

Conclusion

Jerry Jeudy is a high-value buy in dynasty fantasy football for 2025 due to his breakout 2024 season (WR12, 90 receptions, 1,229 yards), youth (26), undervalued ADP (WR39), and secure role as Cleveland’s WR1. His ability to produce in a dysfunctional offense and potential for a quarterback upgrade make him a low-risk, high-reward target.

For contending teams, he’s a cost-effective starter with WR1 upside; for reloading teams, he balances immediate production with future value; and for rebuilding teams, he’s a cornerstone asset with long-term potential. Acquiring him now at a discount (e.g., second-round pick) maximizes value across all team types, especially if the Browns improve at quarterback.

And stay tuned for my next entry in the series: 49ers WR Jauan Jennings!

My first entry in this 3-part series was on Rams WR Davante Adams (shown below).